|
Chiropractic Effectiveness |
| |
|
Chiropractic is
now firmly established as a primary health-care
profession where, according to the American
Chiropractic Association, approximately 7 to 16
percent of people in the United Stated seek
treatment each year. Our profession has earned
recognition for its remarkable effectiveness and
its focus on natural, drug-free, non-invasive
methods of treatment. This section summarizes
the effectiveness of chiropractic for some of
the conditions we treat.
General Lower-Back
Pain
Approximately 25% of our patients come to us with a
chief complaint of low-back/pelvic pain or discomfort. This
pain can be brought on by an accident, overuse, repetitive
stress, emotional stress, or just everyday living.
Several studies have been
conducted to determine the efficacy of spinal manipulation
as a treatment for lower-back pain in general. One of these
involved three chiropractic colleges in California, where
researchers reported that "the trend for spinal manipulation
to produce better results than any form of treatment to
which it was compared was consistent and strong." For 86% of
the outcomes, spinal manipulation was more effective than
any other treatment rendered for lower-back pain.
Additional studies
conducted both in and out of the United States yielded
similar results, where patients reportedly recovered at a
more rapid rate, had fewer relapses, and gained a new sense
of confidence in their movement. Still more investigations
have been conducted on the effectiveness of chiropractic
treatment for two sub-categories of lower-back pain: acute
and chronic.
Acute Lower-Back
Pain
A report published in 1994 by the Agency for Health
Care Policy and Research on acute low-back pain concluded
that spinal adjustment is one of the most effective
treatments for this condition. In another study published in
1994 by the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center and the
Jefferson County (Missouri) Rehabilitation Center, it was
concluded that greater and more rapid improvement occurred
when treated using exercises and spinal adjustment for acute
low-back pain.
A third study conducted by
the Los Angeles College of Chiropractic and the University
of Vermont was published in 1992. These researchers reported
that spinal adjustment, when compared to other methods of
treatment for acute lower-back pain (massage, corset, and
TMS), proved to be a "superior," more effective treatment
after three weeks of care.
Chronic Lower-Back
Pain
In 1997, the Dutch Health Insurance Board funded an
investigation that summarized the results of 48 separate
studies on the effectiveness of chiropractic treatment for
chronic lower-back pain. The investigation determined that
spinal adjustment is more effective than treatments
suggested by general practitioners (bed rest, analgesics,
and massage).
Two similar studies
conducted in Canada in 1985 (University Hospital in
Saskatoon) and 1991 (University of Calgary), plus a third
study conducted in Poland in 1986 (Silesian Medical School),
produced results similar to the Dutch investigation.
Neck Pain
Approximately 19% of our patients come to us with
complaints of neck pain or discomfort. This pain can be
caused by a variety of factors, such as an accident, injury,
overuse, etc. The most common neck condition we address is
whiplash.
The efficacy of
chiropractic for neck pain has been well documented in
numerous studies conducted in the United States, Canada,
Wales, and the Netherlands. In a joint U.S./Canadian study
published in 1996, researchers from UCLA, the West LA
Veterans Affairs Medical Center, and two chiropractic
colleges found that for some patients with sub-acute or
chronic neck pain, spinal adjustment proved to be a more
effective treatment than mobilization or physical therapy.
In a study conducted by the
Canadian Memorial Chiropractic College in Toronto in 1997,
researchers found spinal adjustments to improve neck
mobility and decrease neck pain. An additional Canadian
investigation published in 1997 by the University of Calgary
found spinal adjustments to improve neck mobility and
decrease neck pain in patients having back and/or neck
complaints.
General practitioners in
private practice at the Welsh National School of Medicine
conducted a study of the efficacy of spinal adjustment in
alleviating neck and shoulder pain. The results, published
in 1983, indicated that pain and discomfort improved
significantly after adjustment, as well as range of motion
and flexibility of the affected areas.
A 1992 Netherlands study
conducted by doctors of medicine and other professionals
investigated different methods of treatment for patients
with chronic back and neck pain. After 12 weeks of care,
manual therapy (which consisted of adjustment and
mobilization of the spine) had showed a "faster and larger
improvement in physical functioning" relative to the other
types of treatment such as massage, exercises, and physical
therapy.
Head Pain
Headaches, both tension and migraine, are the chief
complaint for approximately 13% of our patients. Before you
reach for your pain-reliever of choice the next time a
headache or migraine sneaks up on you, consider the
following information on the efficacy of chiropractic care
for head pain.
In a 1995 study conducted
in Minnesota, the effectiveness of spinal adjustment
relative to the administration of an antidepressant drug (amitriptyline)
for patients with chronic tension-type headaches was
investigated. The researchers included doctors of
chiropractic, a doctor of medicine, and another
professionals from Northwestern College of Chiropractic and
the Pain Assessment and Rehabilitation Center, Ltd. They
determined that, after four weeks of treatment, patients
receiving spinal adjustment therapy experienced a continued
lack of symptoms, whereas patients taking the medication
returned to original, baseline conditions.
Another study, published in
1997 by doctors of medicine and doctors of chiropractic at
the University of Odense and the Nordic Institute of
Chiropractic and Clinical Biomechanics in Denmark, compared
spinal adjustment and soft tissue therapy for the treatment
of benign, chronic headaches. They found that both methods
of therapy allowed for significant improvement, and there
were no side effects or signs of worsening associated with
either method.
Carpal Tunnel
Syndrome (CTS)
With a large percentage of the population using keyboards
either at work or at home, CTS is becoming increasingly
common. CTS is a condition where there is a disturbance of
nerve function in the wrist. Because it is a neurological
issue, we are treating more and more patients of all ages
suffering from this malady.
One study, published in
1998 and conducted by researchers from the Northwestern
College of Chiropractic in Minnesota, compared chiropractic
treatment of CTS to conservative medical treatment. The
chiropractic treatment included manipulation, ultrasound
treatment, and wrist supports, while the medical group
received an anti-inflammatory drug (ibuprofen) and wore
wrist supports. They found that both methods of treatment
proved to be equally effective and recommended that patients
with CTS who are sensitive to medical side effects pursue
chiropractic for treatment.
Fibromyalgia
Fibromyalgia is a syndrome characterized by chronic
pain in the muscles and soft tissues surrounding joints,
fatigue, and tenderness at specific sites in the body. While
the cause is unknown, an estimated 3 million people are
affected in the United States. Because we offer a
conservative, hands-on approach to health care, some
patients suffering from fibromyalgia are supplementing their
medical care with chiropractic care.
In 1997, a study was
conducted by three Canadian chiropractors on the
effectiveness of chiropractic care for patients with
fibromyalgia. They reported significant improvement in
flexibility and reduction of pain levels and recommended
that this type of treatment be included along with medical
treatments for this condition.
Infantile Colic
Colic is a condition that occurs in early infancy
and is characterized by episodes of loud crying, apparent
abdominal pain, and irritability. Unfortunately, it is a
common condition that affects approximately 10% of babies in
the United States and lasts from about 2-3 weeks of age
until 3-4 months. While the causes of colic are not always
known or understood, parents of children exhibiting symptoms
of colic are seeking help from chiropractors because of its
effectiveness in reducing the severity of the symptoms.
One study that documents
the efficacy of chiropractic for treating infantile colic
was conducted in 1989 by a doctor of medicine and doctors of
chiropractic at the Anglo-European College of Chiropractic
in Great Britain. Researchers reported that 94% of infants
with colic appeared to be helped by spinal manipulation
within 14 days of the start of treatment. The babies tended
to have both fewer episodes of crying and shorter crying
spells.
Another study, this one
conducted in 1999 in Denmark, investigated two infant
groups: one that was treated with spinal manipulation, and
another that was treated with an over-the-counter antacid
medication (dimethicone). After two weeks, the group treated
with spinal manipulation exhibited a 67% drop in daily hours
of crying, while the dimethicone group experienced a 38%
drop.
Just a sampling
In summary, the above-referenced studies indicate
chiropractic is effective for head, neck, and back pain, as
well as carpal tunnel syndrome, fibromyalgia, and infantile
colic. It is important to note that the conditions discussed
in this section are not the only conditions we treat— this
has simply been a sampling of studies that have been
conducted to determine the efficacy of chiropractic. Our
scope of practice extends well beyond the above maladies,
and we will help you determine if chiropractic care will be
an effective means of treating your particular condition. |